Macadamia Nut Cookie Crusted Mahi Mahi | Nikki's Coconut Butter


Macadamia Nut Cookie Crusted Mahi Mahi

Written by Andrew Frezza | November 04, 2012


We decided to be adventurous and experiment outside of desserts for this one.  Of course, adding Nikki’s Coconut Butter to something already sweet will make it better, but we wanted to be a bit risky, and make something savory and different.


One of our favorite local restaurants, The Food Shack, is famous for making crusted fish, specifically their sweet potato crusted hogfish!  We decided to re-create something similar with our Macadamia Nut Cookie coconut butter and Mahi Mahi!  


The result was DELICIOUS!  Although, I have to say The Food Shack still has us beat!





4 – 6 oz Mahi Mahi fillets (or a mild fish of your choice)


4 oz Macadamia Nut Cookie (Cashew Crumble and Vanilla Cake Batter would be other great options)


1 Tbsp Old Bay Seasoning

Salt and Pepper





Preheat oven to 350 degrees.


Place the fillets on a large baking sheet, and gently spoon coconut butter onto each fillet.  Using your hands, spread the coconut butter making sure most of the fish is coated.


Sprinkle the Old Bay evenly over each fillet.  You can be more generous than 1 Tbsp if you really like the taste of Old Bay.  It will form a nice sweet and salty combination with the coconut butter.  Season each piece with salt and pepper as well.


Bake in the oven for about 15 minutes or until the fish is cooked through.  Once it appears to be done, we suggest turning the oven onto broil and letting the top brown a little bit.  This should take less than a minute or two. 


Now serve and enjoy!


Tagged: coconut butter, macadamia nut cookie, Mahi mahi, paleo, savory